Break Clauses

Break Clauses

Havant International Holdings Ltd. v Lionsgate (H) Investment Ltd. [2000]

Two leases of adjoining commercial premises were granted in 1986, to cover a term from 1985 until 2009. The leases were assigned to the successor of the tenant (HIH) in 1996, and HIH was given the personal right to surrender the lease in 1999 or 2004 if they gave at least 12 months notice in writing.

At all material times after the assignment the premises were occupied by employees of subsidiaries of HIH. HIH did not have employees but had two directors, and in 1998 the directors resolved to exercise HIH’s personal right to surrender the leases. That decision was implemented by one of the employees of a subsidiary company, who instructed solicitors.

[...]

View »

Aberdeen Steak Houses plc v Crown Estate Commissioners [1997]

The landlord granted a lease of the basement of a property, and this was assigned to the claimant tenant. The claimant tenant was protected as a business tenant. In 1994 the landlord decided to redevelop the property and whole premises, so sent to the tenant notice intended to terminate the lease. A covering letter informed the tenant that the notice was being served both under statute and in accordance with the break clause in the lease which provided that if the landlord desired to demolish or reconstruct the property notice in writing was to be given to the tenant. [...]

View »

Mannai Inv. Co Ltd v Eagle Star Life Assurance Co Ltd (1997)

Notices exercising a break clause were effective despite the date behind one day out, as it would still have been obvious to a reasonable recipient that the tenant wanted to determine the lease at the end of the period before the break clause.

 The Landlord, Eagle Star, owned office premises in London which they leased to Mannai Investment Co Ltd.  The lease contained a break clause which allowed the landlord to break the lease by serving 'not less than six months notice in writing .. such notice to expire on the 3rd anniversary of the term commencement date'.

The tenant gave notice to terminate the lease by serving two identical break notices.  The notices were correct save that the termination date of the leases were stated as 12 January 1995 rather than 13 January 1995.  In this case, the [break] clause did not require the tenant to use any particular form of words.  He was simply required to use words which ambiguously convey a particular meaning, namely an intention to terminate the lease on January 13th. The tenant contended that it was clear that the effect of the notices was to determine the lease on 13th January, as this was the only day on which they could have determined. Alternatively, the tenant argued that the notices did not take effect until the moment of time that was both the last moment of January 12th and the first of January 13th, so they did determine the leases on January 13th.

The judge found

[...]

View »

Aylward v Fawaz [1996]

The landlords, Mr & Mrs Aylward, entered into a one year assured shorthold tenancy agreement with the tenant. The agreement contained a break clause allowing either party to bring the tenancy to an end by giving one month notice. This break clause could not be operated during the first six months of the tenancy. On February 13th 1996 the landlords gave notice, in writing, requiring possession of the property after April 14th 1996. The notice contained the following operative words

[...]

View »