Assured Shorthold Tenancy

Assured Shorthold Tenancy

Camelot Property Management v Greg Roynon (2017)

Camelot Property Management Ltd and Camelot Guardian Management Ltd v Greg Roynon (2017)

Bristol County Court, 24 February 2017

Bristol City Council engaged the services of Camelot Property Management Ltd to place 'guardians' in a former local authority care home. Mr Roynon, one of the guardians, had a written licence and paid a rent below the market rent.  Mr Roynon occupied two rooms which only he had access to.  He also had use of other facilities such as a communal kitchen and bathroom.  When the management company served notice on Mr Roynon he refused to leave the property claiming that he was a tenant paying to live in a shared house.

As set out in Street v Mountford [1985] the court will look beyond what the agreement is labelled as and take into account the occupation arrangement.  The court found:

[...]

View »

Mundy v Hook [1997]

The tenant agreed to rent a house from the landlord, and the landlord served a Housing Act 1988 section 20 notice on the tenant stating a term of 6 months. However, the tenancy agreement stated that the term would last 6 months.

The tenant also argued that there was confusion as to whether the garage was included or excluded from the demise as, at the request of the

[...]

View »

Bedding v McCarthy (1995)

In 1990 the tenant entered into an assured shorthold tenancy for a term of 6 months. The notice of assured shorthold tenancy was given to the tenant on the morning of 18th December 1990, and the tenancy agreement was signed that afternoon. The tenant also went into possession that afternoon.

The tenant contended that it could only be an assured shorthold tenancy if the term of the tenancy included the whole of that day, otherwise it was

[...]

View »

Panayi v Roberts (1993)

The landlord granted the tenant a tenancy for a term certain of one year from November 6 1990 of a ground floor flat.  On the same date, the tenant was given notice of an assured shorthold tenancy stating that the tenancy was for a term certain of at least six months. On 16th March 1992, the landlord served a notice requiring possession of the flat on 25th May, under section 2(1) Housing Act 1981. The county court judge made an order for possession.

The tenant appealed, contending that the tenancy granted on 6th November 1990 was not an assured shorthold tenancy because the notice of that

[...]

View »

AG Securites v Vaughan; Antonaides v Villiers [1990]

In two appeals heard together, the House of Lords held that exclusive possession of merely a bedroom is not sufficient to create a tenancy, and also that a tenancy cannot be disguised as a licence by a clause in the agreement which contradicts the character of the agreement.

AG Securities v Vaughan – four separate bedrooms in a house were occupied by four individuals, each with their own independent agreements. Each occupier had exclusive possession of one bedroom, but shared possession of the other parts of the house. The Court of Appeal held that the occupiers were tenants, with a joint tenancy.

Antonaides v Villiers – a couple occupied a one-bedroomed flat, each having a licence which expressly reserved to the owner the right to share and permit other persons to share the flat. This reservation could not reasonably be acted upon, but meant that the couple appeared not to have exclusive possession of the dwelling. The Court of Appeal held that the occupiers had a licence rather than a tenancy.

A further appeal was made to the House of Lords who held:

[...]

View »

Street v Mountford (1985)

Case Summary:

 

Title: Street v Mountford [1985]

This case concerns the distinction between a lease and a licence and the Rent Act 1977

FACTS:  On March 7 1983, Mrs Mountford entered into an agreement described as a licence by which Mr Street granted her the right to occupy two furnished rooms in a house at Nos 5 & 6, St. Clements Gardens, Boscombe for £37 a week, subject to clause 10, 'This licence may be terminated by 14 days written notice ...'

It was conceded by Mr Street that exclusive possession of the two rooms had been granted to the tenant. (key issue)

[...]

View »