Resident Landlord

Resident Landlord

Sumeghovo v McMahon [2002]

A landlord who slept in the house in which he rented a room to a tenant was determined to be a resident landlord, despite spending most of his time in a property he owned next door.

A landlord granted a tenancy of a room in his house. The slept in this house, but spent a lot of time in a neighbouring property that he also owned and for which he was on the electoral role.

The landlord informed the tenant that he needed the room from the a date the following month, and nine days after that month he evicted her and threw her belongings on to the pavement outside. He had not obtained a possession order from the court.

[...]

View »

Resident Landlords under the Housing Act 1988

[...]

View »

Lewis-Graham v Conacher [1992]

As the property rented by the tenant lacked shared gas, electricity and water supplies with the landlord’s residence, despite the interconnecting doors being sealed, the landlord was a resident landlord.

The landlord owned a semi-detached house to which a previous owner had added an extension consisting of a garage and granny flat. The flat had its own front door and number, but it shared a common gas, electricity and water supply with the house. The landlord’s mother lived in the granny flat, which had interconnecting doors to the main house. Following her mother’s death, the landlord sealed the interconnecting doors and let the flat out as furnished accommodation. Three years later building works were done on the flat to make it into a separate dwelling.  Soon afterwards the landlord served a notice to quit on the tenant.

[...]

View »

Palmer v McNamara (1990)

A single room occupied by the landlord was his dwelling-house despite that he did not sleep in it and it did not contain a cooker.

The landlord occupied a ground floor rear room in a flat he owned, and the tenant occupied a ground floor front room. The landlord was in occupation of this room when he granted the tenancy and he continued to occupy it, keeping belongings there such as a fridge, kettle, television and books.

However, the landlord did not have a cooker as he had never learnt to cook, and if he wished to eat in the flat he bought take-away meals or food that did not need to be cooked. Due to a medical condition which prevented him from dressing or undressing himself, he did not sleep in the flat but went to stay in a friend’s spare room each night. 

It was clear that a single room could be a dwelling-house, but it was suggested on behalf of the tenant that a room without a cooker could not be describer as a dwelling house. It was also contended that as the landlord did not sleep in his room he could not be said to be occupying it as his residence. The tenant therefore said that the landlord was not a resident landlord. 

[...]

View »

Wolff v Waddington (1990)

A landlord was a resident landlord as the dwelling occupied by the tenant formed part of the same building as that of the landlord, despite that it was entirely self-contained.

The landlord granted a tenancy of part of an extension to her property. The roof line of the extension was lower than that of the rent of the house, and the tenant’s kitchen was above the landlord/s bathroom, the tenant’s bedroom was above the landlord’s garage and the tenant’s sitting room was above the landlord’s utility room. There was an alleyway, at ground floor only, between the two parts of the house.

The landlord’s mother had occupied the ground floor flat, and since her mother’s death the landlord had lived there continuously (apart from two month-long visits to America). However, the landlord still considered America, which was where her American husband lived, as her home and she intended to return there.

[...]

View »

Barnes v Gorsuch (1982)

An attempt was made to argue that a Victorian house which was in 1959 divided into three flats and subsequently sub-divided into six flats was a ‘purpose built block of flats.

[...]

View »

Griffiths v English (1982)

A landlord who lived in a separate extension to his tenant was regarded a resident landlord as the structure had the appearance of one building and there were not separate gardens.

The landlord owned a house that had a single storey extension built on each side. There were no internal connections. The landlord occupied one extension, and the tenant occupied another. The sole issue to be decided by the court was whether the tenant’s extension formed part of a building that was also occupied by the landlord.

[...]

View »

Bardrick v Haycock (1976)

A landlord who lived in an extension to the main property (which was rented out as six flats) was not a resident landlord as the landlord and tenants could all live entirely separate lives despite being in close proximity.

The landlord owned a large detached house that had been converted into six self-contained flats. The landlord demolished a garage and in its place built a two-storey residential extension. The extension was structurally tied into the main hoa use, but there were no internal communications between it and the main house and it had its own front door.

The landlord let out the flats in the main house and lived in the extension.

[...]

View »