Possession

Possession

Spencer v Taylor [2013]

Spencer v Taylor 2013 EWCA Civ 1600

Mr Spencer granted an assured shorthold tenancy to a Miss Taylor on 6th February 2006 of a property in Chesterfield. The tenancy was granted for an initial fixed term of six months. The rent was paid weekly and according to the tenancy agreement, the first payment became due on the first day of the tenancy (a Monday) and weekly thereafter. The fixed term tenancy expired on Saturday 5 Aug 2006, and was never renewed. By virtue of section 5 of the Housing Act, a periodic tenancy arose immediately thereafter under which the rental periods were also weekly. Under the periodic tenancy, the court calculated that these periods would end on a Sunday presumably because they were linked to the rent payment day
being Monday.

Some time later, Mr Spencer gave notice requiring possession of the property.

[...]

View »

Paratus AMC Ltd v Fosuhene [2013]

Paratus AMC Ltd v Fosuhene [2013] EWCA Civ 827

The borrower let a property without  the lender's consent and defaulted on loan.  The tenant paid rent directly to the mortgage company and when the lender started proceedings for possession the tenant claimed that the payments to the lender made the tenancy binding on the lender. There was nothing to connect those payments to the occupier of the property, but it was claimed that the lender's agent was aware that the property was let following their visit to the property.

The court

[...]

View »

GMAC RFC Ltd v Jones (2010)

GMAC RFC Ltd v Jones (2010) County Court

Ms Jones had a mortgage from GMAC and, on the basis of arrears of mortgage payments, GMAC obtained a possession order.  After the possession order was granted, however, Ms Jones granted a 12 month fixed term assured shorthold tenancy, without getting GMAC's consent. After the end of the fixed term, the tenant remained in occupation, paying rent of £900 per month. GMAC sent notices to the property, addressed to Ms Jones and 'any other occupier', as did another mortgagee also entitled to possession.  The tenant's solicitors requested that no further action be taken for two months. The other mortgagee agreed, but GMAC did not.  The tenant applied to be joined as second defendant and for an order that the execution of the warrant be postponed for two months under s.1(4) of the Mortgage Repossession (Protection of Tenants) Act.

[...]

View »

Suvini v Anderson (2010)

Suvini v Anderson (2010)

It is well known that notices under section 21(4)(a) of the Housing Act 1988 must give notice to a tenant that “after a date specified … being the last day of a period of the tenancy … possession of the dwelling-house is required”. In Church Commissioners v Meya [2006] EWCA Civ 821, the Court of Appeal made a close reading of section 5 of the Act and held that it should be construed as reading that the length of the periods of a statutory periodic tenancy created by that section “are the same as [the periods] for which rent was last payable under the fixed term tenancy.”

In this case a property was let from 18 August 2007 to 17 August 2008 with a rent of £1,200 payable on the 15 August 2007. A further tenancy was granted for another 12 months from 18 August 2008 to 17 August 2009, rent being payable bi-monthly in advance starting on the 11 August 2008. After August 2008 the tenancy continued on a periodic basis. A notice under section 21(4)(a) was served on 1 April 2010 seeking possession “after 17 June 2010 or, if later, the day on which a complete period of your tenancy expires next after the end of two months from the service of this notice.”

[...]

View »

Notting Hill Housing Trust v Roomus (2006)

A s. 21 notice was valid, as 'after the end of the tenancy' means the same as 'at the end of the tenancy', so use of either in a s. 21 notice is allowed.

The tenant was granted an assured shorthold tenancy of premises.  The landlord, the Notting Hill Housing Trust, then applied for a possession order under section 21 of the Housing Act 1988.  The tenant was issued with a standard form section 21 notice but claimed that it was not valid.  It was submitted that the notice was invalid because it contained the phrase "at the end of the period of your tenancy" instead of "after the end of the period of your tenancy". Section 21 of the Housing Act 1988 requires

[...]

View »

North British HA v Matthews [2004]

The claimants were all tenants of housing associations under assured tenancies. They had fallen into arrears of rent, so possession proceedings were started. There was no dispute that both at the date of the service of the notice of proceedings under section 8 of the Housing Act 1988 and at the date of the hearing, the arrears exceeded the 8 weeks limit specified in ground 8. Therefore, it appeared that  in each case the court was obliged by section 7 of the Act to make an order for possession. 

[...]

View »

McDonald v Fernandez [2003]

Landlords who did not comply precisely with the specific requirements of s. 21 as the date specified on the notice was not the last day of one period but the first day of the following period were not entitled to possession.

The tenants were granted an assured shorthold tenancy for 6 months from 4th September 1999 to 3rd March 2000. After this period had expired, they remained in the property as statutory periodic tenants from the 4th of each month to the 3rd of the following month. On 24th October 2002 the landlords gave them a notice headed 'Section 21(4)(a) - Assured Shorthold Tenancy: Notice Requiring Possession: Periodic Tenancy', stating that the landlords required possession on 4th January 2003. The tenants unsuccessfully argued that this notice was not effective as the date specified was not the last day of a period, but instead was the first day of the following period.

On appeal: [...]

View »

Tuohy v Bell (2002)

A tenant was committed to prison for failing to comply with a possession order.

The trustee in bankruptcy for Mr and Mrs Tuohy obtained a court order against them for the sale of their matrimonial home, with possession to be given by 11 October 2001. In August 2001 the trustee obtained a warrant for possession, as he knew that the couple would not leave voluntarily. The bailiff tried to execute this warrant on 15 October 2001 but Mr and Mrs Tuohy refused to leave. The trustee in bankruptcy applied for them to be committed to prison for contempt of court in refusing to comply with the order for possession and the warrant. At the time that the application was heard, later in October, Mrs Tuohy had left the property. The application was defective, so the judge adjourned the hearing until 5 November in order for Mr Tuohy to obtain legal representation. He warned Mr Tuohy that if he failed to comply with the order for possession he could be sent to prison. At the adjourned hearing, Mr Tuohy said that he would not leave unless he was thrown out or sent to prison. Mr Tuohy could have applied to set the warrant aside, but unless he had done the warrant was valid. Mr. Tuohy was committed to prison for seven days, so that possession could be obtained peacefully. Mr Tuohy appealed.

HELD:

[...]

View »

Laine and Mitchell v Cadwallader & Cadwallader (2001)

This case concerned tenants, Mr & Mrs Cadwallader who held a periodic assured shorthold tenancy under the Housing Act 1988.  The tenants got behind with their rent, surrendered the keys to the landlord, and promptly left the property.  The landlord brought legal action against the tenants for rent arrears, damage to the property, and rent in lieu of notice.  Case concerned tenant's notice to quit during periodic tenancy. Case confirmed that common law position applies to this situation and tenant liable to paying rent in lieu of notice.

[...]

View »

Barrett v Morgan [2000]

A tenant’s co-operation and consent to being served a notice to quit does not constitute surrender, because the landlord does not require the tenant’s consent in order to terminate the tenancy.

The owner of agricultural land granted a tenancy to two individuals (his sons), who then themselves granted a sub-tenancy to a farmer who farmed the land. The owners and the head-tenants wanted to obtain vacant possession of the land so that they would be able to sell it with vacant possession, so agreed that the owners would serve a notice to quit on the head-tenants. The head-tenants agreed not to serve any counter-notice relying on the relevant provisions of the Agricultural Holdings Act 1986.

The purpose of this agreement was to enable the owners to obtain possession against the sub-tenant farmer, as it was believed that when the notice to quit the head-tenancy expired, both the head tenancy and the sub-tenancy would come to an end.

Although this scheme was effected by the owners serving a notice to quit on the head-tenants, it originated from the two head-tenants. The head-tenants were unable to obtain vacant possession against the sub-tenant by serving on him notice to quit, because the sub-tenant would have been able to rely on the protection given by the 1986 Act. The head-tenants believed that they could not gain possession even by serving a notice to quit themselves, because case law at that time meant that a tenant could no impair or destroy the interest that he had granted to a sub-tenant just by putting an end to his own tenancy. They therefore concluded that the solution was for the tenancy to be ended by the owners.

[...]

View »

Taj v Ali [2000]

A landlord successfully appealed against the suspension of a possession order against his tenant, as it would mean that the tenant would be repaying the rent arrears for an almost indefinite period.

A county court judge made an order for possession of a property belonging to the claimant landlord, on the ground of rent arrears owed by the tenant. The order also provided, by consent, for the tenant to pay the landlord £14, 503 rent arrears plus interest, minus an agreed deduction in respect of the tenant’s counterclaim for breach of the landlord’s repairing obligations.
As the tenant was on income support, the judge suspended the possession order on terms that the tenant should pay the current rent of £49 per week, plus £5 per week towards the discharge of the rent arrears. It was known that this would mean that the debt would not be paid off for over 55 years.

The landlord appealed against the suspension of the possession order.  HELD:

[...]

View »

Drew-Morgan v Hamid-Zadeh [1999]

A s. 21 notice was held also to have been valid as a s. 48 notice, as it provided the tenant with the landlord’s name and an address at which notices could be served.

A landlord granted a tenancy of a flat to a tenant, believing it to be an assured shorthold tenancy. When he wanted to terminate the tenancy, the landlord therefore served a s. 21 notice with a view to using the accelerated procedure provided for by s. 21 to recover possession on the termination of the tenancy. The s. 21 notice recorded the landlord’s name and the name and address of her solicitors, who were described as the ‘landlord’s agent’. The landlord later invoked the accelerated procedure by serving a county court application (s. 21 application), in which the name and address of the same solicitors was inserted into a printed box with the cation ‘for service and payment’. The landlord obtained a possession order, but the tenant successfully applied for a rehearing. The s. 21 application was later consolidated with new proceedings brought by the landlord. This claim was founded on Ground 2 of statutory grounds for possession and alleged that the tenant had persistently delayed paying rent ‘which has become lawfully due’. At the rehearing, the s. 21 was [...]

View »