This case concerns the applicability of the Unfair Contract Terms Regulations 1999 to agency contracts, and more particularly, to commission rates.
There has been substantial enforcement activity of the unfair terms regulations by the OFT in recent years but little actual case law which clarifies the true legal position. This case is, therefore, significant for letting agents as it examines the legality of price escalation clauses and similar ‘penalty clauses’ in agency agreements.
Owners of a flat in London wished to sell it, and entered into a ‘Confirmation of Marketing Agency Agreement’ with Bairstow estate agency. The written agreement contained a clause that the clients would pay the standard commission rate of 3% of the final sale price of the property (plus VAT), but that the discounted commission rate for early payment was 1.5% (plus VAT).
On the other side of the agreement were the terms and conditions, stating that Bairstow would charge a ‘commission fee’ in relation its marketing of the property. This fee would be earned if, during the period of the agreement, Bairstow introduced a buyer to the property or entered negotiations with the person who later contracted to purchase the property. The discounted fee was available only if payment was made within 10 days of the completion date; if it was not then the standard rate would be applicable and interest (at 3% above the base rate) would accrue.
Bairstow introduced a buyer, and the sale was completed. The fee was indisputably payable, but the clients’ solicitors did not pay the full 1.5% commission within 10 days. There was nearly £400 unpaid when 10 days expired, despite that the funds were in place and the solicitors had authority to make the full payment.
Bairstow was quite tolerant of this, but three months later claimed the entirety of the 3% standard rate fee (minus the amount already paid). However, they did make it clear that if the outstanding £387 due under the discounted rate was paid, they would not seek to recover the extra under the standard rate. (This extra under the 3% standard rate amounted to almost £3,000.) No payment was made, and Bairstow took action against the clients. Before the proceedings the £387 was paid, but they continued to the court.
Subscription Required
In order to view our entire Case Law Library and Letting Factsheets, a membership is required. We offer a range of plans to suit all business, starting with our Silver plan all the way up to Pro-Gold.
Plans start from just £50 (£60 inc VAT) p/a