Rogerson v Bolsover District Council [2019] EWCA Civ 226, 26 February 2019

Mrs Rogerson, a council tenant, had a tenancy which started on 7th September 2014.  Mrs Rogerson was mowing the front garden when she stepped backwards onto an inspection cover which gave way.  She fell through the cover into the sewerage void beneath.  The cover and support were owned by Severn Trent Water.  Mrs Rogerson suffered injuries, loss and damage as a result of the incident and made a claim against the landlord (Bolsover District Council). The question here is when is the landlord’s duty under section 4 Defective Premises Act 1972 engaged and is there any duty to inspect.  The landlord had conducted an inspection of the property in May 2013 and a survey in January 2014.  Expert evidence showed that the manhole, the void and the cover would be about 40 to 60 years old and it was clear that it was beginning to corrode away causing the support provided by the framework to deteriorate over a period of time.  This meant that the inspection cover was not able to take the tenant’s weight and it is likely that the corrosion with the rain water has affected the mortor and, therefore caused the stability of the inspection cover to fail.  The District Judge found that

Subscription Required

In order to view our entire Case Law Library and Letting Factsheets, a membership is required. We offer a range of plans to suit all business, starting with our Silver plan all the way up to Pro-Gold.

Plans start from just £50 (£60 inc VAT) p/a