Anchor Hanover Group v Cox [2023]
Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), 17th January 2023
This case was initially heard by the First-tier Tribunal who ruled in favour of the tenant who believed the landlord was responsible for repairs to the lift in a block of retirement flats under s11 Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. Anchor Hanover Group appealed to the Upper Tribunal who were asked to decide if s11 prevented a landlord from recovering a service charge for contributions towards the cost of repairing a lift.
The tenant lived in a four storey purpose built block of retirement flats under an assured tenancy as part of a social housing scheme. The flats were occupied by elderly and infirm residents. It was a term of the tenancy agreement that the landlord would repair the communal lift and the tenant would pay a service charge towards the cost of repairs. Some tenants were elderly or infirm and the tenant advised that a properly functioning lift was essential and therefore the landlord’s responsibility. The tenant argued that he shouldn’t be responsible for contributing towards the cost of repairs to the structure of the building.
The First-Tier Tribunal (FTT) concluded that the lift was an installation covered under s11 LTA 1985 and S11(1B) required the landlord to repair common parts of the building. The FTT ruled that the landlord was therefore required to keep the lift in proper working order and the term in the tenancy that the tenant would pay towards the cost of repairs had no effect.
The Upper Tribunal believed the FTT’s analysis of section 11 was astray. Martin Rodger KC, Deputy Chamber President agreed with the finding that the lift is a common facility and that it was essential to the residents of the building but ‘the leap from identifying something as a common facility and concluding that it is therefore an installation to which section 11(1)(b) applies is insupportable.”
The Upper Tribunal concluded that the lift did not form part of the structure or exterior of the building or the tenant’s flat, and it was not an installation for the supply of water, gas, electricity or sanitation, nor for space heating or heating water. As a result, the lift works did not fall within s.11. the tenant was liable for the service charges.
N.B. This case relates to routine maintenance and service charges for the lift not repairs to a broken down lift. Where residents are elderly or infirm and the lift has broken down or is not functioning then this may result in the property being unfit for human habitation under s.9A and s.10 Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 requiring the landlord to cover the costs of repair and major works